Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

Serving Sarasota With Heart

From Osprey to downtown Sarasota, Susan brings unmatched local knowledge and a personal touch, helping buyers and sellers navigate each neighborhood with confidence.

13

Closed Sales

$7.6M

Total Value

$464.1K - $860K

Price Range

5+

Years of Experience

Susie Pelton

Susie Pelton

REALTOR®

With 30 years of Sarasota residency and a background in healthcare and business, Susan takes a holistic approach to real estate. She combines deep market knowledge with a passion for helping clients, ensuring each decision is informed and stress-free. Known for her meticulous, concierge-style service, Susan listens closely to her clients’ needs, guides them through every step of buying or selling, and makes the process as enjoyable as possible.

Beyond real estate, she is deeply involved in the community, supporting children’s organizations and military families, and brings the same dedication to her clients’ homes as she does to her family and community.

WHAT CLIENTS SAY

When helping individuals transition from their homes to our senior living community, it is imperative that we have personable and professional realtors with impeccable credentials at our disposal, and we are fortunate to have someone as accomplished as Susie that we can count on. Susie is always well-prepared and always smiling-who could ask for more?

— Scott S.

WHAT CLIENTS SAY

Susan was very proactive and responsive to our needs. She worked tirelessly to find us our new home, which had a lot of boxes to check. She was very patient with me when I rejected a lot of homes. In the end, the outcome was exceptional! I would definitely recommend her to anyone looking for a home in Sarasota.

— Nita K.

WHAT CLIENTS SAY

Susie made being a first-time homeowner painless and simple. She was able to answer any questions I had in a timely manner while always giving fantastic suggestions for future plans. She really hustled to find exactly what I wanted and couldn’t be happier with the result.

— Trace C.

WHAT CLIENTS SAY

Susie was very professional and actually listened to my requirements, which was the key to finding the right house.

— Buyer

WHAT CLIENTS SAY

Happy ending! Susie was very professional and actually listened to my requirements, which was the key to finding the right house.

— Nita & Mark

WHAT CLIENTS SAY

Susie was always prompt with return calls and thorough with researching options available in the market. She was very knowledgeable about the process status of city or county and home inspections. Overall, she made the entire process simple and was a joy to work with!

— Seller

WHAT CLIENTS SAY

Working with Susan has been a wonderful experience. Her knowledge and guidance helped us get the perfect dreamhouse! I would highly recommend Susan.

— Darlene

WHAT CLIENTS SAY

The buying experience was overall exceptional. Personable, attentive, and knowledgeable of the market. We have used her twice, and her pleasant personality made the stressful experience transpire with ease!

— Marsha A.

WHAT CLIENTS SAY

Susie is such a nice lady, always checking in and always going above and beyond to help. When we were almost to drop out of the deal, she was there to fight for us and secured the deal.

— Buyer

WHAT CLIENTS SAY

Working with Susan was such a pleasure. She was always there for me with any information or questions I had. Working with her has been such a great experience.

— James & Darlene K.

How Much is Your Home Worth?

  • Instant property valuation
  • Expert advice
  • Sell for more

Work With Susie

Dedicated, attentive, and deeply connected to the Sarasota community, Susie delivers a refined, client-first real estate experience. She is committed to making the process smooth, transparent, and rewarding.